2003
Megan Routh – Orrville High School, Ashland University
Ryan Gallagher – Wooster High School, Julliard School
Rachel Briceland – Dalton High School, Spring Arbor University

2004
Rachel Kincaid – Wooster High School, Eastman School of Music
Andrew Tucker – Orrville High School, Ashland University
Cortney Fry – Smithville High School, Westminster College

2005
Emily Tibbitts – Orrville High School, Ashland University
Joy Steiner – Waynedale High School, Malone College
Linda Miller – Waynedale High School, Malone College

2006
Jaclyn Hennell – Orrville High School, Ball State University
Belita Schloneger – Central Christian High School, Indiana Wesleyan University

2007
Andrea Blaine – Wooster High School, Otterbein College
Nathan Rehm – Wooster High School, Capital University

2008
Ashley Boggs – Dalton High School, The University of Akron
Ruth Messner – Dalton High School, Grove City College

2009
Michael Lucas – Chippewa High School, The University of Akron

2010
Erika Stafford – Orrville High School, Waynesburg University

2011
Peter Douglas – Dalton High School, Baldwin-Wallace College Conservatory of Music
Alisa Murray – Central Christian High School, Hesston College
Andrew Shaffer – Wooster High School, Ashland University

2012
Emily DeVincent – Wooster High School, The Ohio State University
Bethany Marty – Wooster High School, Baldwin-Wallace College Conservatory of Music

2013
Nathan Negro – Northwestern High School, Youngstown State University
Aaron Pfahler – Kingsway Christian School, Huntington University

2014
Joellen Eades – Home School/Central Christian High School, Cedarville University
Emily Ebert – Waynedale High School, College of Wooster

2015
William Myers – Orrville High School, The University of Akron

2016
Meredith Eades – Home School/Central Christian High School, Malone University
Jacob Steiner – Smithville High School, The University of Akron

2017
Kayla Fisher – Smithville High School, University of Cincinnati Conservatory of Music
Brianna Potts – Waynedale High School, University of Mount Union

2018
Elizabeth Maiwurm – Orrville High School, The University of Akron
Ethan Mann – Triway High School, Ohio Northern University

2019
Savannah Johns – Orrville High School, Asbury University

2020
Trevor Walton – Orrville High School, Kent State University

2021
Logan Mann – Triway High School, Otterbein University

2022
Brooklyn Schlabach – Waynedale High School, University of Mount Union

2023
Joshua Rittgers – Orrville High School, Asbury University